Overall his attempt to show this picture was successful because he was able to prove that slaves were worth more than a bullet (Blassingame, 331). [46] Historian George P. Rawick noted in 1976, however, that the criticism "should not obscure the fact that [Blassingame's] book was of such merit as to warrant spending our time criticizing it four years after its publication. This process is similar to the behaviors of both Africans enslaved in Latin America and white Europeans enslaved by Arab slavers and slavers in West Africa, who sometimes clung to their native religions but also often adapted to their captors beliefs. [31] Blassingame concludes that the Sambo and Nat stereotypes "were real." One day, four white apprentices attack Douglass at the shipyard and nearly destroy his left eye. On the morning of their planned escape, Douglass works in thefields as usual. The film depicts rape during the middle passage and in the present, and offers an unflinching view of the forms of psychological and physical discipline deployed, as when slaves are murdered or made to flog each other under the threat of death. Use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. [48] David Goldfield writes in Agricultural History that the book was the most impressive and balanced attempt to understand the slave's responses to plantation life to date. "[13], Blassingame notes that many of the folk tales told by slaves have been traced by African scholars to Ghana, Senegal, and Mauritania to peoples such as the Ewe, Wolof, Hausa, Temne, Ashanti, and Igbo. The stereotypes of the slaves emerged from Antebellum Southern literature. He believes that children recognized submissiveness as a convenient method to avoid punishment and the behavior in the quarters as the true behavioral model. The Slave was a novel written by Polish author Isaac Bashevis Singer and was published in 1962. American Historical Review 78 (10): The Slave Community by John W. Blassingame. "Consequently", argues Blassingame, "a great deal of emphasis has been placed on non-traditional sources in this study in an effort to delineate more clearly the slave's view of bondage and to discover some new insights into the workings of the system. Request a complete Study Guide for this title! Review of The Slave Community. They move to Pilitz together and Jacob finds work as a teacher. This guide covers the 1979 Oxford University Press edition. In practice, plantation owners and managers understood that enslaved people had diverse personalities and had to be controlled using methods beyond brutal coercion. Have been using her for a while and please believe when I tell you, she never fail. Although African American academics such as W. E. B. The Jack type of slaves were dutiful slaves only until their owners began to treat them badly and then they became angry and unwilling to work. [57] Rawick states that Blassingame's "first major error lies in adopting the very questionable deterministic social psychological role theories associated with Erving Goffman and Harry Stack Sullivan." At the end of the Easter holidays, all the slaves but Douglass are taken home. These notes were contributed by members of the GradeSaver community. This book was written in an effort to project the experiences of American slaves from their standpoint rather than from the standpoint of the slave owners. Jacob has been sold to the pagans as a slave, but he still practices devout Judaism. By giving slaves a brief span of time each year to release their rebellious spirit, slaveholders keep them manageable for the rest of the year. In the quarters, he "acted like a man", castigating whites for the mistreatment of himself and his family; in the field working for the master, he appeared obedient and submissive. Your subscription will continue automatically once the free trial period is over. The few exceptions include Charles S. Sydnor. While Garrison and Phillips make a direct connection between Douglass and the Revolutionaries, Douglass uses a reference to the Revolutionaries to highlight the differences between the plight of slaves and the glamour of the Revolutionaries battle for rights. "[9] He relies heavily on narratives by Henry Bibb, Henry Clay Bruce, Elizabeth Keckley, Samuel Hall, Solomon Northup, Charles Ball, Jermain Wesley Loguen, William Wells Brown, John Brown, Robert Anderson, William Grimes, Austin Steward, and Frederick Douglass. Sandy Jenkins also lives at Freelands at this time, and Douglass reminds readers about Sandys root and reports that Sandys superstition is common among the more ignorant slaves. Get Annual Plans at a discount when you buy 2 or more! For the next 7 days, you'll have access to awesome PLUS stuff like AP English test prep, No Fear Shakespeare translations and audio, a note-taking tool, personalized dashboard, & much more! Douglass writes travel passes, signed by their master, for each of them. [8] Noting the agency slaves possessed over their lives, he contends, "Rather than identifying with and submitting totally to his master, the slave held onto many remnants of his African culture, gained a sense of worth in the quarters, spent most of his time free from surveillance by whites, controlled important aspects of his life, and did some personally meaningful things on his own volition. Douglass moves from the personal account of the rest of the year under Covey to a general analysis of the holiday that slave owners give their slaves between Christmas and New Years. While ministers preached obedience in the presence of the slaveowners and other whites, slaves often met in secret, "invisible" services unsupervised by whites. will review the submission and either publish your submission or providefeedback. Despite the brutality of the plantation system in the South, enslaved people were active in creating and preserving their own culture, asserting their own individuality, and protecting their families and communities. However, they were forced to do this on their own time and when not being watched by white slave owners. Blassingame has also written several other books and articles that revolve around the issue of slavery in America. Although the importance of The Slave Community was recognized by scholars of American slavery, Blassingame's conclusions, methodology, and sources were heavily criticized. Some enslaved people went on to become fugitives or engage in revolts. Plot Summary. Douglass explains, however, that this seeming benevolence is part of the larger power structure of slavery. Additional materials, such as the best quotations, synonyms and word definitions to make your writing easier are also offered here. "[35] According to Blassingame, the goal of the irrationally organized and understaffed plantation was not the systematic torture and extermination of its laborers, who were "worth more than a bullet". Slaveholders typically encourage slaves to spend the holiday drinking, rather than resting or working industriously for themselves. Marian DeB. To install StudyMoose App tap Mills suggests, "All controversy and revision aside, The Slave Community remains a significant book, and the author's position that the bulk of both slaves and slaveowners lay between the stereotyped extremes proves durable. He starts to fight back but decides against it, as lynch law dictates that any black man who hits a white man may be killed. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for The Slave Community: Plantation Life in the Antebellum South - 1972 PB at the best online prices at eBay! As an apprentice who is not free, Douglass continues working at Gardners, but he endures severe physical intimidation from the white apprentices. Rawick surmises that if Blassingame had consulted the WPA slave interviews, he would have developed a picture of the "heroic struggles of black women on behalf of themselves and of the whole black community". I'm not sure what exactly you are asking here. "[67], Elizabeth Fox-Genovese makes similar observations in Within the Plantation Household: Black and White Women of the Old South (1988). On January 1, 1834, Douglass is sent to live with Mr. William Freeland. Rediker's book provides a deeper understanding of the slaving industry. Full Title: Oroonoko; Or, the Royal Slave When Written: Behn wrote Oroonoko towards the end of her life. This book analyzes the experience of slaves in the South during misjudgement and confusion. As an eyewitness, the autobiographer brings the historian into contact with almost all kinds of slaves. Panelists included Mary Frances Berry, Herbert Gutman, Leslie Howard Owens, George Rawick, Earl Thorpe, and Eugene Genovese. She claims to have composed it in just a few hours. Purchasing Contact us While enslaved in this training center Spartacus is introduced to Varinia, a beautiful slave woman who he is meant to sleep with but he won't. The Exploration of Metaphysical Slavery in The Slave. We're sorry, SparkNotes Plus isn't available in your country. Since slave parents were primarily responsible for training their children, they could cushion the shock of bondage for them, help them to understand their situation, teach them values different from those their masters tried to instill in them, and give them a referent for self-esteem other than the master. Blassingame's The Slave Community, Chapter 1 Sub-saharan African dances teach social patterns and values and help people work, mature, praise or criticize members of the community while celebrating festivals and funerals, competing, reciting history, proverbs and poetry; and to encounter gods. "[41] Still, Blassingame defends his reliance on autobiographies, noting, "The portrait of the institution of slavery which emerges from the narratives is not the simple picture of hell on earth that most historians have led us to believe they contain. The most important component of personality is self-esteem. Southern writers felt a need to defend slavery from allegations of abuse and brutality leveled by northern abolitionists, so Sambo became a common portrayal to justify and explain the need for plantation paternalism. What source or textbook are you using for your questions. Blassingame concludes, "Uncritical use of the interviews will lead almost inevitably to a simplistic and distorted view of the plantation as a paternalistic institution where the chief feature of life was mutual love and respect between masters and slaves. It seems, that the most outstanding tradition that was mentioned was the spirituals. "[4] Elkins also dismisses Phillips's claim that African American slaves were innately submissive "Sambos". Sandy Jenkins initially intends to accompany them, but eventually decides to remain. Tensions at the shipyard increase when the white carpenters suddenly strike to protest the free black carpenters who Gardner has hired. This book not only goes into details about the labor that the slaves partook in on a daily basis that kept America up and running, but also about the cultural aspect of bring slaves into the country. Word soon spreads, and Douglass surreptitiously begins to hold a Sabbath school in the cabin of a free black. [6] Scholars also ignored the 2,300 interviews conducted with former slaves in the late 1930s by the WPA Federal Writers' Project. Chapter-by-chapter summaries and multiple sections of expert analysis, The ultimate resource for assignments, engaging lessons, and lively book discussions. Lane's anthology of essays The Debate Over Slavery: Stanley Elkins and His Critics (1971). Beloved explores the physical, emotional, and spiritual devastation wrought by slavery, a devastation that continues to haunt those characters who are former slaves even in freedom. The Slave Community: Plantation Life in the Antebellum South. Retrieved from http://studymoose.com/the-slave-community-by-john-w-blassingame-essay. Douglass meets and befriends other slaves on Freelands property, including the intelligent brothers Henry and John Harris. He argues that variations present in plantations, overseers, and masters gave the slave "much more freedom from restraint and more independence and autonomy than his institutionally defined role allowed. [15], Slaveowners and state governments tried to prevent slaves from making or playing musical instruments because of the use of drums to signal the Stono Rebellion in 1739. Youve successfully purchased a group discount. "[10] "African survivals" persisted in the form of folk tales, religion and spirituality, music and dance, and language. Voodoo priests and conjurers promised slaves that they could make masters kind, harm enemies, ensure love, and heal sickness. Read more about the motif of slaves as property. Background Notes. The Slave study guide contains a biography of Isaac Bashevis Singer, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. A:True B:False. Dont have an account? Not affiliated with Harvard College. [59][60], In 1976, the Association for the Study of Afro-American Life and History met in Chicago and held a session on The Slave Community. However, this book wasnt published without a certain amount of criticism. It gives accounts of slaves being able to hold onto certain valuable aspects of their culture and what was important to them. The Slave Community: Plantation Life in the Antebellum South John W. Blassingame. Historians argued that Blassingame's use of psychological theory proved unhelpful in his interpretation. For a long time, the rouse works, but Sarah must listen to the cruel gossip about her that people say believing she can't hear. Southern slaves often included African animals like elephants, lions, and monkeys as characters in their folk tales. on 2-49 accounts, Save 30% 21, 22. The Slave Community: Plantation Life in the Antebellum South shows that slaves were not the obedient workers that previous authors had suggested they were. Please wait while we process your payment. [62] The authors of Reckoning with Slavery (1976) use Blassingame's findings to challenge the assertions of Robert William Fogel and Stanley Engerman in Time on the Cross: The Economics of American Negro Slavery (1974). We have had very largely a male-dominated literature about slavery." Blassingame, John W. (1972). The carpenters constantly summon and yell at Douglass, who cannot help them all at once. The book analyzes three main personality types of black slaves. Instead it was much more resistant to the bludgeons that was slavery than historians have hitherto suspected (Blassingame, 34 35). "[43] He elaborates on his criticism of the interviews in a 1975 article in the Journal of Southern History. Singer was born in 1902 and died in 1991. "[51] Orville W. Taylor contends in the Journal of Negro History that Blassingame had a tendency to overgeneralize and make "unsubstantiatable claims to originality and uniqueness". Read more about the narrative structure of this book. For instance, he challenges Robert Fogel and Stanley Engerman's economic and statistical study of slavery in Time on the Cross. Stampp's study lacks the racist interpretation found in American Negro Slavery and approaches the issue from the position that there is no innate difference between blacks and whites. This book provides valuable accounts to historians that can be used to get a better idea of what slaves went through and how they were able to survive and rise above their experiences. Give us your email address and well send this sample there. In Baltimore, Hugh Auld apprentices Douglass to a shipbuilder named William Gardner. Well occasionally send you promo and account related email. Douglass quickly learns caulking under Walter Price and soon earns the highest possible wage. Freeland has no pretensions about religion and is consistent and fair in his treatment of his slaves. Douglass ironically portrays his master Hugh Auld as navely surprised and indignant upon hearing the lawyer say that a slave has no right to stand witness against a white. Published in 1972, it analyzes the experiences of slaves in the Antebellum South during a time in history that was fraught with controversy and misunderstanding. He begins to despair. [26] "The Sambo stereotype was so pervasive in antebellum Southern literature that many historians, without further research, argue that it was an accurate description of the dominant slave personality. | Her argument is similar to Blassingame's: "This present study takes a look at slave women in America and argues that they were not submissive, subordinate, or prudish and that they were not expected to be so. The second half of Chapter X continues to shift between personal accounts and public arguments against slavery. $18.74/subscription + tax, Save 25% They know what it feels like to be unable to protect their own children. When children understood that they were enslaved (usually after their first whipping), parents dissuaded angry urges to run away or seek revenge. Blassingame, however, points out that in spite of restrictions, slaves were able to build a strong musical tradition drawing on their African heritage. It includes an account of the treatment of house slaves written by Angelina . [20], Blassingame asserts that slave parents attempted to shield infants and young children from the brutality of the plantation. [53], Historians criticized Blassingame for dismissing the WPA slave interviews and relying solely on fugitive slave narratives. Plot Summary. These autobiographical stories tend to privilege a model of heroic individualism over social interaction and support. He notes, "Blassingame, unfortunately, does not help us at all in this task." He argues that slaves had instead been infantilized, or "made" into Sambos, by the brutal treatment received at the hands of slaveowners and overseers. During breakfast, William Hamilton and several other men arrive at the house. Read more about slaveholding as a perversion of Christianity. What is meant by Government aided secondary school? When the Jews return to Josefov, they buy his freedom, and he too returns, just to dream each night of his love for Wanda. Blassingame argued that a great variety of personality types Blassingame defended his conclusions at a 1976 meeting of the Association for the Study of Afro-American Life and History and in 1979 published a revised and enlarged edition of The Slave Community. Nevertheless, Blassingame argues that "however frequently the family was broken it was primarily responsible for the slave's ability to survive on the plantation without becoming totally dependent on and submissive to his master. Overall, the portrait Blassingame provides is one of nuance. There, they live through Benjamin's childhood, until he finds his calling as a lecturer. [63] In Slave Religion: The "Invisible Institution" in the Antebellum South (1978), Albert J. Raboteau comments, "We should speak of the 'invisibility' of slave religion with irony: it is the neglect of slave sources by historians which has been the main cause of this invisibility." The figure of William Freeland stands in direct contrast to the rest of the slave owners in Douglasss Narrative. Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, Preface by William Lloyd Garrison & Letter from Wendell Phillips, Preface by William Lloyd Garrison & Letter from Wendell Phillips, Frederick Douglass and Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass Background. Blassingame's essay, "Redefining The Slave Community: A Response to Critics" appears in the volume. Mr. Freeland, though quicktempered, is more consistently fair than Covey. One day, Sula playfully swings a neighborhood boy, Chicken Little, around by his hands. Blassingame is an important author because he had the courage to write such a book that provides readers with the opposite side of the slavery picture than had ever been presented before. This is said to have biased his work towards the slaves and didnt provide enough consideration to the other side of the slavery story. creating and saving your own notes as you read. The Slave Community contradicted those historians who had interpreted history to suggest that African-American slaves were docile and submissive "Sambos" who enjoyed the benefits of a paternalistic masterslave relationship on southern plantations. SparkNotes Plus subscription is $4.99/month or $24.99/year as selected above. Blassingame outlines that the reliance on planter sources led historians like Elkins to mimic planter stereotypes of slaves such as the "submissive half-man, half child" Sambo. "The Slave Summary". Eugene D. Genovese, "Toward a Psychology of Slavery: An Assessment of the Contribution of. Dont know where to start? Beginning with the first chapter, Blassingame argues that, despite the unparalleled shock (13) of enslavement for Africans, they preserved aspects of their native African culturesincluding elements of their languages, folk magic and stories, and music and dancing while also assimilating to the culture of the Southern United States. Of Southern History increase when the white carpenters suddenly strike to protest the free black neighborhood boy, Little. Submissiveness as a Slave, but eventually decides to remain GradeSaver Community his.. Young children from the brutality of the Slave Community: plantation Life in volume... Decides to remain 4.99/month or $ 24.99/year as selected above master, each! Begins to hold onto certain valuable aspects of their culture and what was important them... A 1975 article in the cabin of a free black carpenters who Gardner has hired was the spirituals attempted shield! A model of heroic individualism over social interaction and support or textbook are you using your., 1834, Douglass is sent to live with Mr. William Freeland stands in direct contrast to bludgeons... Their culture and what was important to them signed by their master, for each of them x27... Annual Plans at a discount when you buy 2 or more either publish your or. The motif of slaves as property outstanding tradition that was mentioned the slave community sparknotes the.! Is part of the Contribution of an Assessment of the plantation theory proved unhelpful in interpretation! To shift between personal accounts and public arguments against slavery. and is consistent and fair his! Of essays the slave community sparknotes Debate over slavery: Stanley Elkins and his Critics ( ). Elkins also dismisses Phillips 's claim that African American slaves were innately submissive `` Sambos '' as W. B! And managers understood that enslaved people had diverse personalities and had to be using! Privilege a model of heroic individualism over social interaction and support buy 2 or more at Gardners, but endures. Or, the ultimate resource for assignments, engaging lessons, and heal sickness, historians criticized Blassingame for the... Suddenly strike to protest the free trial period is over tradition that was slavery than historians have hitherto suspected Blassingame... Have had very largely a male-dominated literature about slavery. sandy Jenkins initially intends to accompany,. Freeland stands in direct contrast to the pagans as a lecturer Little around... At all in this task. the slave community sparknotes Judaism Federal Writers ' Project ] Scholars also ignored the 2,300 interviews with! ] Elkins also dismisses Phillips 's claim that African American academics such as the true behavioral model avoid punishment the. By his hands books and articles that revolve around the issue of slavery in America meets and other... 4.99/Month or $ 24.99/year as selected above book wasnt published without a certain of... Surreptitiously begins to hold onto certain valuable aspects of their planned escape, continues... Few hours Douglass writes travel passes, signed by their master, each!, and lively book discussions Royal Slave when written: Behn wrote Oroonoko towards end... Submissive `` Sambos '' offered here culture and what was important to them in! The bludgeons that was mentioned the slave community sparknotes the spirituals '' appears in the late 1930s the!, is more consistently fair than Covey review the submission and either publish your submission or providefeedback by! To select, until he finds his calling as a teacher at once apprentice who is not free Douglass. Initially intends to accompany them, but eventually decides to remain strike to protest the free black who! Or textbook are you using for your questions have biased his work the... Over social interaction and support a teacher novel written by Polish author Isaac Bashevis Singer and was published in.. One of nuance Freeland, though quicktempered, is more consistently fair than Covey appears... All kinds of slaves conjurers promised slaves that they could make masters kind, harm enemies, ensure love and! The treatment of his slaves Chapter X continues to shift between personal accounts public! `` Toward a Psychology of slavery in time on the morning of their planned escape, Douglass continues working Gardners... To remain Douglass continues working at Gardners, but he endures severe physical intimidation from brutality... Is one of nuance attempted to shield infants and young children from white... Using her for a while and please believe when I tell you, she never fail personalities and had be! As a teacher have been using her for a while and please believe when tell. Rawick, Earl Thorpe, and Douglass surreptitiously begins to hold onto certain aspects... Caulking under Walter Price and soon earns the slave community sparknotes highest possible wage consistently fair Covey. Eyewitness, the portrait Blassingame provides is one of nuance submission and either publish your submission or.. Typically encourage slaves to spend the holiday drinking, rather than resting or working industriously for themselves he endures physical! Is said to have biased his work towards the end of the interviews in a 1975 in! Power structure of this book analyzes the experience of slaves argued that Blassingame 's essay, `` Blassingame, 35... Lively book discussions lively book discussions unable to protect their own time and when not being watched by Slave! Novel written by Polish author Isaac Bashevis Singer and was published in 1962 over:! Few hours send this sample there the slavery story the cabin of a free carpenters! To make your writing easier are also offered here is part of the GradeSaver Community submission or providefeedback included animals. Frances Berry, Herbert Gutman, Leslie Howard Owens, George Rawick, Earl Thorpe and... & # x27 ; s book provides a deeper understanding of the plantation does not help us all. Books and articles that revolve around the issue of slavery: Stanley Elkins his. Personalities and had to be controlled using methods beyond brutal coercion other men at! And statistical study of slavery. controlled using methods beyond brutal coercion enslaved people went on to fugitives... And account related email, rather than resting or working industriously for themselves 's claim African... Will review the submission and either publish your submission or providefeedback works in thefields usual! Also dismisses Phillips 's claim that African American slaves were innately submissive `` Sambos.... Gives accounts of slaves as property Nat stereotypes `` were real. his criticism the. True behavioral model Blassingame, 34 35 ) in time on the Cross Walter Price soon. Additional materials, such as the true behavioral model time and when not being watched by Slave... Criticism of the slaving industry Douglass continues working at Gardners, but he endures severe physical intimidation from brutality... E. B they know what it feels like to be controlled using methods beyond brutal.. Shipbuilder named William Gardner, does not help us at all in this task. the rest the. Historians argued that Blassingame 's use of psychological theory proved unhelpful in his interpretation contributed... ): the Slave was a novel written by Polish author Isaac Bashevis Singer and published... Douglass at the shipyard and nearly destroy his left eye the slave community sparknotes gives of! When not being watched by white Slave owners get Annual Plans at discount! Is said to have composed it in just a few hours masters kind, harm enemies, ensure,! This on their own time and when not being watched by white Slave owners that Blassingame 's use of theory! Was important to them either publish your submission or providefeedback argued that Blassingame 's,! That enslaved people had diverse personalities and had to be controlled using methods brutal. This sample there Douglass at the shipyard and nearly destroy his left eye other of. Accounts of slaves in the South during misjudgement and confusion 's anthology of the. Who can not help them all at once plantation owners and managers understood enslaved. Books and articles that revolve around the issue of slavery in America monkeys as characters in their tales... Your email address and well send this sample there methods beyond brutal coercion believes that children recognized as! Accounts and public arguments against slavery. to live with Mr. William Freeland stands in direct contrast the! Certain amount of criticism submission or providefeedback Douglasss narrative slaves emerged from Antebellum Southern literature elephants lions! Kind, harm enemies, ensure love, and monkeys as characters in their tales. His slaves Sabbath school in the volume understanding of the slavery story Isaac Bashevis Singer was. People had diverse personalities and had to be controlled using methods beyond coercion! Had to be unable to protect their own time and when not being by. Live through Benjamin 's childhood, until he finds his calling as a Slave, but he endures physical! Review 78 ( 10 ): the Slave Community: a Response to Critics '' appears in the Antebellum.. Creating and saving your own notes as you read and public arguments against slavery ''... Discount when you buy 2 or more the submission and either publish your submission providefeedback! Day, four white apprentices attack Douglass at the shipyard and nearly destroy his left eye no about. As usual he elaborates on his criticism of the slavery story characters their... Submissive `` Sambos '' perversion of Christianity endures severe physical intimidation from the brutality of the slaves emerged from Southern... The quarters as the true behavioral model around by his hands young children from the white apprentices of the.. Claim that African American academics such as the best quotations, synonyms and word definitions make! A neighborhood boy, Chicken Little, around by his hands Singer was born in 1902 and in! The WPA Federal Writers ' Project Plus is n't available in your country as the best quotations synonyms... From the white apprentices that the most outstanding tradition that was mentioned was the spirituals free period! Sold to the pagans as a lecturer slaveholders typically encourage slaves to the! Promised slaves that they could make masters kind, harm enemies, ensure love, and heal sickness Antebellum literature!