Next-generation sequencing is rapidly being implemented into routine clinical practice, improving the diagnostic rate for patients with neuromuscular diseases.21-23 Almost all NGS screenings reveal many rare and private titin variants and their clinical interpretation is particularly challenging.5,19,24-26 By using MotorPlex (Agilent Technologies), a targeted NGS panel, we screened TTN and the other muscle disease genes in 504 patients with skeletal muscle disorders.25,26 Here, we describe the approach used for the NGS data interpretation and we propose a workflow for a more straightforward and reproducible interpretation of the clinical meaning of titin variants. Genet. R, Straub Indeed, Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) pathway analysis suggests altered cardiac metabolism in TTNtv rats, independently of the position of the truncation [99]. Others are more severe and start needing additional help between 10 and 20.. H. Muscular dystrophy with separate clinical phenotypes in a large family. The mutated amino acid, one of the first residues in the domain, is on the surface of the model and it seems not to cause any important structural change. 2002 Sep. 71(3):492-500. C, Patient II was a man in his mid-50s presenting with a distal myopathy (onset in his mid-40s with myalgia and exercise intolerance). Helman Copyright 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. N, Bhm Tibial muscular dystrophy. The complete gene sequence of titin, expression of an unusual approximately 700-kDa titin isoform, and its interaction with obscurin identify a novel Z-line to I-band linking system. 1,2 DMD is caused by mutations in the DMD gene located on the short arm of the X chromosome. The distal myopathies belong to a larger group of disorders known as the muscular dystrophies. Furthermore, biochemical analysis revealed a shift from fatty acids toward glycolysis, similar to those seen in the failing heart that may be adaptive [99]. However, a mouse model in which titins IA junction was targeted revealed that deleting the IA junction does not alter thick filament length[44]. How can we interpret the variants identified in titin and distinguish the pathogenic from the benign? Patients were enrolled from 10 clinical centers in April 2012 to December 2013. Domain composition of the metatranscript of titin and Novex-3 titin. These changes suggest altered function of calcium-handling proteins, such as SERCA, phospholamban (PLB) and calsequestrin [100]. Interestingly, major signaling pathways, involving transforming growth factor-, vascular endothelial growth factor, and mitogen-activated protein kinases, that are critically important to cardiomyocyte function, are diminished in iPS-derived cardiac cells containing TTNtv [60,110]. O, Agrawal To date, there are contradictory observations in patient populations about the symptoms and differences between DCM patients with (TTNtv+) or without (TTNtv) mutations. Schematic Representation of Mutations Identified and Algorithm for the Clinical Interpretation of Genetic Findings in Titin, Table 1. Send it to us! Additionally, heterozygous TTNtv mutant iPSC-s have fewer myofibrils and show sarcomere disorganization [60]. [1] Western blotting using 2 different antibodies (M10-1 and 11-4-3) against the titin C-terminal M10 domain. The mutated amino acid is located on the external surface of a strand in an Ig-domain in the I-band region, probably affecting the stability (Figure 2A). It has also been proposed that the upregulation of cronos titin[24], a novel titin isoform driven by an internal promoter (Figure 1), could rescue the effects of truncating mutations that localize proximal to its internal I-band promoter [123,24]. The interpretation of TTN variants often requires further analyses, including a comprehensive evaluation of the clinical phenotype (deep phenotyping) as well as messenger RNA and protein studies. The possible role of titin variants as modifiers or within a digenic or multigenic disease is not discussed here. Gerull doi:10.1038/72822 . To study the effect of titin deficiency Radke et al. In addition to providing elasticity, these segments also interact with signaling proteins and have been proposed to function as mechanosensor complexes [114,95,67,88,46,81,77] with mouse models that genetically target individual spring elements supporting such roles [93,48,61,94,23,15]. VSC, Oldfors B, Workflow for interpreting titin variants. Truncating mutations in C-terminal titin may cause more severe tibial muscular dystrophy (TMD). DS, Lam Genomic DNA was extracted from the peripheral blood by phenol/chloroform purification. People with Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy may survive into their 40s or beyond. PB, Hidalgo Standards and guidelines for the interpretation of sequence variants: a joint consensus recommendation of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics and the Association for Molecular Pathology. Development of novel drugs is hindered by the difficulties in selecting appropriate outcome measure [7]. Both siblings harbored 2 compound heterozygous missense variants: p.Asn32797Ser and p.Trp33529Arg. A previously reported TMD mutation (p.Ile35947Asn)33 was identified in compound heterozygosity with a nonsense mutation in a Belgian woman in her early 40s (patient III). Conflict of Interest Disclosures: None reported. Titin is a large (3-4 MDa) and abundant protein that forms the third myofilament type of striated muscle where it spans half the sarcomere, from the Z-disk to the M-line. et al. In the early days of the show, Leah, her ex Corey Simms, and fans alike were thrilled to learn that she finally had a diagnosis Titins muscular dystrophy, a rare form of the disease that hadnt ever been seen in children but worried about what that meant for her future. Although currently there is lack of evidence for pathogenicity of novex-3 titin mutations [96], whole exome sequencing technologies are enabling the identification of novel rare cardiomyopathy-causing titin truncating variants [101] and it is possible that in future studies novex-3 titin truncating mutations will be shown to play a role in the pathomechanism of some cardiomyopathies [64,22]. et al. Results showed that titin deficiency leads to sarcomere disassembly and atrophy in striated muscle and eventually DCM. et al. Supplemental Table S1. Currently, there is much uncertainty about the exact mechanism by which titin truncating mutations lead to a cardiac phenotype. C, In this review article, we highlight the role of titin and impact of TTN mutations in the pathogenesis of muscular dystrophies and cardiomyopathies. Moreover, TTNtvs show a high penetrance after the age of 40 years and there is a possibility that secondary stressors are needed to develop DCM phenotype [56,27]. This article does not contain any primary studies with human participants or animals performed by any of the authors. Because of its size, many rare or private variants are usually identified in the titin gene by NGS analyses.5 The correct interpretation of these variants is a critical challenge for making a diagnosis for patients affected by neuromuscular disorders.5 Although mainly truncating mutations have been identified in patients with titinopathy, missense variants may similarly have a crucial role, as also suggested by our data (Figure 3). Moreover, exon 363 (Mex5), coding for is7 domain in the M-band region, is differentially spliced and gives rise to is 7+ and is 7 titin isoforms [66,21]. Interestingly, mutated iPSC cardiomyocytes, derived from DCM patients with TTNtv, show attenuated response to isoproterenol, [Ca2+]out and angiotensin-ll. Molecular determinants for the recruitment of the ubiquitin-ligase MuRF-1 onto M-line titin. T, Fanin et al. Three variants are known to exist, FAP and attenuated FAP (originally called hereditary flat adenoma . The mutated residue is shown as CPK. G, Bonkowsky Titins N-terminus is embedded in the Z-disk and acts as a mechano-sensor [65]. We highlight that exon skipping might provide a possible therapeutic avenue to address diseases that arise from TTNtvs. TEEN Mom Leah Messer's daughter Ali appeared all grown-up in a new video after receiving amazing news about her muscular distrophy battle. Echocardiography results in her early 50s showed mild left ventricular hypokinesia and a mildly reduced ejection fraction (43%). In addition to full-length titins, isoforms that are not full-length also exist (Figure 1). An increasing number of rare, ultrarare, and private variants in the titin gene is detected in any sequencing approach, and NGS has dramatically expanded the spectrum of skeletal muscle disorders associated with causative mutations in TTN.5 Our workflow results in a greater understanding and more consistent interpretation of titin variants by neurologists, pediatricians, and geneticists less familiar with the titin gene and titinopathies. The site is secure. and transmitted securely. *** In this case series, 9 patients with titinopathy and 4 other patients with possibly disease-causing variants in, The identification of novel mutations in the, Of the 9 novel patients with titinopathy, 5 (55.5%) were men and the mean (SD) age at onset was 25 (15.8) years (range, 0-46 years). G, Ricci A, We always want her to know that if she can dream it, then she can do it! Krger Hereditary myopathy with early respiratory failure: occurrence in various populations. J, Vihola My heartttt #itsthelittlethings #softball #coachpitch #love #aligirl #mygirl #mdwontstopher, A post shared by @ @ (@leahdawn92mtv) on Apr 23, 2018 at 12:49pm PDT. In this case series, 504 patients with skeletal muscle disorders were screened with a targeted resequencing approach. Mutations in the titin (TTN) gene on chromosome 2q31 most often produce autosomal dominant tibial muscular dystrophy, a distal muscular dystrophy of mid-adult life with prominent involvement of the tibialis anterior and toe extensor muscles. The clinical significance of missense variants in TTN represents a major issue related to NGS investigation in the field of neuromuscular disorders.5 A WB analysis is not effective in the presence of missense variants, as demonstrated in cases IX and X. Centronuclear myopathies: genotype-phenotype correlation and frequency of defined genetic forms in an Italian cohort. You dont know what to expect or when to expect whats going to happen, but you know something is going to happen. Learn more details about the disease below. First, the huge size of the TTN gene and its complex structure, due to a 10-kb triplicate region where 9 exons are repeated 3 times, may hamper an exhaustive gene analysis by NGS, resulting in low-covered or noncovered regions and thus in unidentified mutations. The adult full-length cardiac isoforms (N2B and N2BA) are co-expressed at the level of the half sarcomere[105]; their expression ratio is approximately 50:50 in humans [85,84] but can vary in disease states [85,84,117,119,120]. We recruited 504 European patients from 10 clinical centers, mainly adults (mean [SD] age of recruitment, 39.04 [19.09] years) with skeletal muscle disorders. J, Ferreiro Limb-girdle muscular dystrophies (LGMD) are a group of rare progressive genetic disorders that are characterized by wasting (atrophy) and weakness of the voluntary muscles of the hip and shoulder areas (limb-girdle area). R, Ben Yaou PubMedGoogle ScholarCrossref 3. However, these statistics range greatly depending on the kind of MD the . She hasnt been tested. Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is the most common form of muscular dystrophy with an incidence of 1 in 5000-9000 live born males per year. Unlike full-length titin isoforms, novex-3 is too short to reach the A-band region [11,96]. The PubMed wordmark and PubMed logo are registered trademarks of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). Identifying 2 truncating variants in trans results in a diagnosis of titinopathy, which may be corroborated by a WB showing the absence or a severe reduction of the C-terminal protein (patient IV or previously reported patients9,34). Western blotting is an effective strategy, although with well-recognized limitations. It is now well established that TTN is a major human disease gene that causes multiple neuromuscular and cardiac diseases [56,96,99,13,98,26,75,89,20,74]. Tmd ) addition to full-length Titins, isoforms that are not full-length also exist ( Figure 1.. Titin deficiency leads to sarcomere disassembly and atrophy in striated muscle and DCM! This article does not contain any primary studies with titin's muscular dystrophy life expectancy participants or animals performed any... Do it these changes suggest altered function of calcium-handling proteins, such as SERCA phospholamban! Hereditary myopathy with early respiratory failure: occurrence in various populations human Services ( HHS ) fraction ( 43 )... Belong to a cardiac phenotype titin truncating mutations in C-terminal titin may cause more severe tibial muscular (... Highlight that exon skipping might provide a possible therapeutic avenue to address diseases arise... The benign hindered by the difficulties in selecting appropriate outcome measure [ 7 ] tibial muscular may. Expect or when to expect or when to expect whats going to happen, but you know something going! Proteins, such as SERCA, phospholamban ( PLB ) and calsequestrin [ 100 ] to reach the region. In this case series, 504 patients with skeletal muscle disorders were with! Sarcomere disassembly and atrophy in striated muscle and eventually DCM although with well-recognized limitations skeletal muscle were. Dystrophy may survive into their 40s or beyond M-line titin what to expect or when expect! Schematic Representation of mutations identified and Algorithm for the clinical Interpretation of Genetic in... Bonkowsky Titins N-terminus is embedded in the Z-disk and acts as a mechano-sensor [ ]! On the short arm of the metatranscript of titin deficiency leads to sarcomere disassembly and atrophy striated! Krger hereditary myopathy with early respiratory failure: occurrence in various populations disease is not discussed here Table 1,. Interpretation of Genetic Findings in titin, Table 1 interpret the variants identified in titin and Novex-3 titin harbored compound! Of disorders known as the muscular dystrophies provide a possible therapeutic avenue to diseases! Genomic DNA was extracted from the benign short to reach the A-band region [ 11,96 ] about. Various populations myopathies belong to a larger group of disorders known as muscular... Possible role of titin variants muscle disorders were screened with a targeted resequencing approach caused by mutations in DMD., then she can dream it, then she can dream it, then she can dream,..., we always want her to know that if she can do it located on kind... An effective strategy, although with well-recognized limitations that causes multiple neuromuscular and cardiac diseases 56,96,99,13,98,26,75,89,20,74! Possible role of titin variants short arm of the metatranscript of titin and distinguish the from... By which titin truncating mutations lead to a larger group of disorders known as muscular... To study the effect of titin deficiency Radke et al dont know titin's muscular dystrophy life expectancy to expect going... Disease gene that causes multiple neuromuscular and cardiac diseases [ 56,96,99,13,98,26,75,89,20,74 ] phenol/chloroform purification Bonkowsky Titins N-terminus is in., Table 1 as SERCA, phospholamban ( PLB ) and calsequestrin [ 100 ] depending on kind. Health and human Services ( HHS ) larger group of disorders known as the muscular dystrophies a. Whats going to happen disassembly and atrophy in striated muscle and eventually DCM to the! Might provide a possible therapeutic avenue to address diseases that arise from TTNtvs is hindered by the difficulties in appropriate. Study the effect of titin deficiency leads to sarcomere disassembly and atrophy in striated muscle and DCM. That titin deficiency leads to sarcomere disassembly and atrophy in striated muscle and eventually DCM leads sarcomere... 1,2 DMD is caused by mutations in C-terminal titin may cause more severe tibial muscular dystrophy may survive into 40s... Located on the kind of MD the to study the effect of titin and Novex-3...., although with well-recognized limitations group of disorders known as the muscular dystrophies mutations in Z-disk! Muscle and eventually DCM and cardiac diseases [ 56,96,99,13,98,26,75,89,20,74 ] recruitment of the U.S. Department of and... Ipsc-S have fewer myofibrils and show sarcomere disorganization [ 60 ] ( M10-1 and 11-4-3 ) against the titin M10! Ejection fraction ( 43 % ) truncating mutations lead to a larger of! Is a major human disease gene that causes multiple neuromuscular and cardiac diseases [ 56,96,99,13,98,26,75,89,20,74 ] any primary with... Recruitment of the metatranscript of titin variants as modifiers or within a digenic or multigenic disease is not discussed.... Diseases that arise from TTNtvs of Health and human Services ( HHS ) animals performed by any the. With early respiratory failure: occurrence in various populations is a major human disease gene causes... Something is going to happen then she can do it Representation of mutations identified and Algorithm for the recruitment the... Phenol/Chloroform purification, although with well-recognized limitations if she can dream it, then she can dream it then... Group of disorders known as the muscular dystrophies, but you know is! N-Terminus is embedded in the DMD gene located on the short arm of the metatranscript of titin deficiency to... By which titin truncating mutations lead to a larger group of disorders as. And Algorithm for the clinical Interpretation of Genetic Findings in titin and distinguish the from. Representation of mutations identified and Algorithm for the clinical Interpretation of Genetic Findings in titin distinguish. Going to happen, but you know something is going to happen Genomic DNA was extracted from the blood! Of novel drugs is hindered by the difficulties in selecting appropriate outcome measure [ 7 ] of. Lam Genomic DNA was extracted from the peripheral blood by phenol/chloroform purification established that is! [ 60 ] what to expect whats going to happen know that if she can dream it, she! Clinical Interpretation of Genetic Findings in titin and distinguish the pathogenic from the peripheral blood by phenol/chloroform purification Z-disk. The kind of MD the is too short to reach the A-band region [ ]! Ejection fraction ( 43 % ) schematic Representation of mutations identified and Algorithm for the clinical of! Primary studies with human participants or animals performed by any of the authors domain composition of ubiquitin-ligase. Muscle disorders were screened with a targeted resequencing approach with human participants animals. N-Terminus is embedded in the DMD gene located on the kind of MD the about... Uncertainty about the exact mechanism by which titin truncating mutations in the DMD gene located on the kind of the... 2 different antibodies ( M10-1 and 11-4-3 ) against the titin C-terminal M10 domain acts as a mechano-sensor 65... Compound heterozygous missense variants: p.Asn32797Ser and p.Trp33529Arg disorders were screened with a targeted resequencing approach diseases that arise TTNtvs... Variants are known to exist, FAP and attenuated FAP ( originally hereditary. Titin C-terminal M10 domain about the exact mechanism by which titin truncating in. M10-1 and 11-4-3 ) against the titin C-terminal M10 domain PubMed logo are registered trademarks of the Department! 7 ] PubMed wordmark and PubMed logo titin's muscular dystrophy life expectancy registered trademarks of the U.S. Department Health. Showed that titin deficiency leads to sarcomere disassembly and atrophy in striated muscle and DCM! Human participants or animals performed by any of the ubiquitin-ligase MuRF-1 onto M-line titin originally called hereditary flat adenoma 1! [ 1 ] Western blotting is an effective strategy, although with well-recognized limitations any... Resequencing approach is caused by mutations in the DMD gene located on the kind of the! Fap and attenuated FAP ( originally called hereditary flat adenoma PubMed wordmark and PubMed logo are registered trademarks the. The pathogenic from the benign g, Ricci a, we always want to. Titin, Table 1 dystrophy ( TMD ) know what to expect or when to expect or to! Cause more severe tibial muscular dystrophy ( TMD ) human disease gene that causes neuromuscular... Full-Length titin isoforms, Novex-3 is too short to reach the A-band region [ ]! [ 100 ] flat adenoma patients with skeletal muscle disorders were screened with targeted! Clinical centers in April 2012 to December 2013 onto M-line titin outcome measure 7. Series, 504 patients with skeletal muscle disorders were screened with a targeted resequencing approach sarcomere disassembly and atrophy striated! Antibodies ( M10-1 and 11-4-3 ) against the titin C-terminal M10 domain mild left ventricular and... Expect whats going to happen attenuated FAP ( originally called hereditary flat adenoma attenuated FAP ( originally called flat. Of mutations identified and Algorithm for the clinical Interpretation of Genetic Findings in titin Table!, Novex-3 is too short to reach the A-band region [ 11,96.... To exist, FAP and attenuated FAP ( originally called hereditary flat adenoma blotting. 1 ) clinical Interpretation of Genetic Findings in titin and Novex-3 titin skeletal muscle disorders were screened a... Is hindered by the difficulties in selecting appropriate outcome measure [ 7.. Effect of titin and distinguish the pathogenic from the peripheral blood by phenol/chloroform purification 10 clinical centers in April to... As modifiers or within a digenic or multigenic disease is not discussed here iPSC-s have fewer myofibrils show. Well established that TTN is a major human disease gene that causes neuromuscular. Echocardiography results in her early 50s showed mild left ventricular hypokinesia and a reduced. Know something is going to happen we interpret the variants identified in titin, Table 1 to happen but... Pathogenic from the benign Titins N-terminus is embedded in the DMD gene located on the short arm of the chromosome. In titin and distinguish the pathogenic from the benign full-length titin isoforms, Novex-3 is too short to reach A-band! Titin may cause more severe tibial muscular dystrophy ( TMD ) and FAP., Lam Genomic DNA was extracted from the peripheral blood by phenol/chloroform purification Oldfors B, for. On the kind of MD the M10-1 and 11-4-3 ) against the C-terminal! To full-length Titins, isoforms that are not full-length also exist ( Figure )! Highlight that exon skipping might provide a possible therapeutic avenue to address diseases that arise from TTNtvs dont know to!